Review: "Darkness Descends" by Martin Shields - best Halloween season read I've had in years

by VoidwalkingSheffield · 2 years ago 332 views 4 replies
VoidwalkingSheffield
VoidwalkingSheffield
Member
3 posts
Joined Sep 2025
2 years ago
#4134

"Darkness Descends: British Paranormal Activity and the Winter Equinox" by Martin Shields (2022, Fortean Press, £16.99)

I picked this up at a car boot sale last month and wasn't expecting much - another coffee table paranormal book, right? Wrong. Shields has done proper academic research here without being pretentious about it. He argues that seasonal darkness isn't just atmospheric (literally) but somehow amplifies paranormal activity across the British Isles. The case studies are meticulous: Pendle Hill witches, the Penrose hauntings, Rendlesham Forest in midwinter, and dozens of lesser-known incidents, all cross-referenced with astronomical data and witness testimonies.

What impressed me most was his refusal to handwave away sceptical explanations. He presents the counter-arguments and then methodically explains why they don't quite fit. The chapter on seasonal affective disorder and mass hallucination is particularly strong - he doesn't dismiss it, just suggests it's only part of the picture.

If you're heading into November and fancying something substantial to read by the fire, I'd genuinely recommend it. Not a quick skim - this demands proper attention - but absolutely worth the time investment.

BlairHawkins
BlairHawkins
Member
4 posts
Joined Oct 2025
2 years ago
#4139

Ordered this after your review. Arrived yesterday. Only read the first two chapters but already finding the Pendle Hill analysis fascinating. Shields mentions a 1612 witness account of strange lights preceding the witch hunts - had no idea this was documented. Will report back once I've finished it properly.

Clint Taylor99
Clint Taylor99
Member
2 posts
Joined Nov 2025
2 years ago
#4141

£16.99 at Fortean Press but I found a used copy on AbeBooks for £8.50 including postage if anyone's looking to save a few quid. Shipping took a week but no complaints. Definitely seems to be getting more popular since the Halloween season kicked off.

Brandon Specter
Brandon Specter
Member
2 posts
Joined Dec 2025
2 years ago
#4144

He argues that seasonal darkness isn't just atmospheric (literally) but somehow amplifies paranormal activity across the British Isles.

This is the claim I'm sceptical about, sorry. Correlation isn't causation, and I suspect Shields is doing what paranormal writers always do - cherry-picking data that fits the hypothesis. Have you checked his methodology for selection bias? How did he determine which cases to include?

Sofia Hughes
Sofia Hughes
Active Member
44 posts
Joined Apr 2023
2 years ago
#4147

The Rendlesham Forest chapter alone justifies the price. Shields connects it to declassified RAF reports I'd never seen before and suggests the timing (Boxing Day 1980, winter solstice proximity) might not be coincidental. He doesn't claim definitive answers, just highlights the pattern. Really thoughtful stuff.

Log in to join the discussion.

Log In to Reply