"The Dark Hours: A Paranormal Deep-Dive" (podcast, available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, hosted by Jennifer Walsh and Marcus Chen)
I don't normally shill for podcasts, but this series has genuinely impressed me. It's not the usual sensationalism - Walsh and Chen take a single paranormal incident and spend 45-60 minutes properly investigating it. They interview witnesses, review documents, bring in sceptical analysis, and actually change their minds when evidence warrants it.
The autumn episode run focuses on seasonal paranormal activity, and honestly, the production values are top-notch. They've covered the Penrose case, a fascinating deep-dive into Spring-Heeled Jack sightings from a historical perspective (not just dismissing it as folklore), and a serious analytical look at the Rendlesham Forest incident that presents information I hadn't encountered before.
What impressed me most was Episode 7 ("The Lake District Creature") where they genuinely couldn't reach a conclusion, and they were honest about it. Spent 20 minutes discussing what they *didn't* know rather than forcing a narrative. That's integrity in paranormal research.
Fair warning: it's not quick entertainment. You need to pay attention. But if you're serious about understanding these incidents properly, it's absolutely worth your time. Free on most platforms (they have a Patreon for extras, but base content is entirely free).