Saw this thread and had to comment because yeah, something in that third photo looks off. Not saying it's definitely anything but the shape near the doorway doesn't match any of the people who were supposedly on that floor at the time. Has anyone actually overlaid the group photos to check where everyone was standing?
Also curious whether anyone ruled out lens flare or shadow from the torch beam. I know that sounds boring but you have to eliminate the obvious stuff first or people just pick it apart. Been on a few hunts near Whitby and half the "figures" I thought I caught turned out to be my own shadow bouncing off wet stone walls which was deeply embarrassing.
If someone can post the raw unedited version I'd actually look properly. The compressed jpeg versions that get shared round on here are useless for analysis.